“I, I, I: I am this, I can do this, I must do this”
The Lost Daughter“I, I, I: I am this, I can do this, I must do this” is the narrator’s emphatic formulation of selfhood at the moment her academic work receives public recognition. Its repeated first person turns a conference triumph into a declaration of identity and capacity, even as news of her daughter Marta’s illness presses against that newly claimed sense of possibility.
The Moment of Assertion
After Professor Hardy cites and admires the narrator’s article, she leaves the hall and runs to her room, overwhelmed by pride. She telephones her husband in Florence to tell him what has happened. His response brings news that Marta has chicken pox, a detail that would ordinarily provoke anxiety. Instead, the narrator describes the illness as entering her amid a changed emotional landscape: not the emptiness she associates with earlier years, but a future filled with joy, power, and confusion.
The phrase arrives as the culmination of this bodily and emotional surge. The narrator says that all the liquids inside her seem to be boiling beneath her skin; recognition is felt not as an abstract professional success but as a physical disturbance. The repeated “I” gives that sensation a verbal shape, moving from existence (“I am this”), to ability (“I can do this”), to necessity (“I must do this”).
Recognition and Selfhood
The declaration follows a sharp change in the narrator’s standing at the conference. Before Hardy’s talk, she had been an obscure graduate student, seated at the back of the hall; when he discusses her published article with admiration, colleagues search for her, and her professor’s attitude becomes newly kind. By lunch, she understands that she has shifted, within an hour, from anonymity to the status of a young scholar with some international recognition. The repeated first person answers this external reclassification with an inward claim: she is not only someone whom others have noticed, but someone who can pursue further work.
That claim is especially pointed because the recognition is attached to authorship. Hardy has used her writing to develop his own argument, and her professor urges her to finish another essay quickly. The phrase’s sequence therefore links identity to action and future labor. It does not announce that her circumstances have been resolved; it insists, in the wake of a specific success, that she can and must continue.
Maternal Anxiety and the Unresolved Tension
The phone call places Marta’s chicken pox beside the narrator’s professional exhilaration. The narrator knows the illness is definite, confirmed by a doctor, yet her first response is to think that Bianca has had it too and Marta will recover. For a moment, the usual wave of maternal anxiety does not produce the familiar emptiness. Instead, the news becomes part of a “blissful confusion” in which physical pleasure, intellectual triumph, and concern coexist.
The phrase does not erase motherhood or the daughter’s illness; it records the narrator’s attention turning forcefully toward herself at a moment when she might otherwise have been absorbed by family worry. Its insistence is therefore both affirmative and unsettled. The three clauses make selfhood sound like a discovery, a capability, and an obligation, while the circumstances around them preserve the competing demands that this new assertion has not made disappear.
